Basically, I'm going to list Sonic characters that I was planning to put on my overrated/underrated lists but didn't. Either because they weren't as overrated/underrated as any other characters I listed or I couldn't really think of much to say about them. Also these are all my opinions so don't get upset.
She was supposed to be in my underrated Sonic characters list because she does get hated alot especially from Classic fans. Ironically, Amy was introduced during the Classic era. But she's pretty well liked as well so I decided it was unnecessary.
Scourge the Hedgehog
Originally, supposed to be in my overrated list. Like Shadow and SatAM Robotnik, he's thought of as ultimate badass that can beat the shit out of anyone. There are other people who consider him overrated. These lists should be based on my own opinions not other people's and I don't consider him as overrated as Shadow or SatAM Robotnik. So he didn't make it. As for the whole Sonic recolor stuff. He is Sonic from another dimension, so what do you expect?
Characters from the Sonic manga
I'm mainly talking about the one about Nicky, a hedgehog who can turn into Sonic. This manga and it's characters are very underrated and I wanted to mention them since very few fans even know it exists. The problem was I couldn't think of much to say about them because I don't know much about them. It would probably be hard for me to read these comics, especially in English. So, sadly I didn't talk about them.
Cosmo the Seedrian
Once again this is a character that I felt was underrated but I haven't seen too much of Sonic X to give a final verdict.
Marine the Raccoon
Yes! I think Marine is underrated. I didn't think she was as annoying as other people did. But I couldn't think of much to say about her so she was out. I doubt anyone minds though.
SatAM/Archie Freedom Fighters
I was planning on putting the SatAM/Archie Freedom Fighters on my overrated Sonic characters list but I couldn't get myself to do it. I know I originally put Sally on the list but after thinking a little I took her off. The reason is because of all the annoying SatAM fans who constantly parade these characters like their the best thing ever and claim that the characters in the recent games suck and the SatAM cast should be in it instead, especially Sally. Oh, and don't get me started on how butthurt some of them are about whatt's happening recentely in the Archie comics. "Sally's been roboticized. Ian Flynn is the worst writer ever." If you don't like what's happening in the comics right now, then don't read them. BTW Be on the lookout for when I give my thoughts on the Archie and Fleetway comics. Man, I rant about this stuff alot. Also, just because I think something or someone is overrated doesn't mean I don't like them. There are a few exceptions like Invader Zim. I do like these characters just not as much as other people do.